« Free Resources from Please Convince Me | Main | Obama a Muslim? »

March 05, 2008

Comments

Melinda, I'm a little confused by your third paragraph. Are you saying that the pluralists's objection to Christian theism is a dismissal, or that Plantinga's objection to pluralism is a dismissal?

Jeffrey,

Melinda doesn't come around these parts (the comments) much, so I'll take a stab. The objection she called a "dismissal" was the one she noted in the first paragraph - "Religious belief is too culturally and historically conditioned to be 'truth.'" In this conext, Plantinga wasn't giving an objection to pluralism but rather a rebuttal to to the original objection. Hope that helps!

Thanks, Aaron, that makes sense.

The comments to this entry are closed.